If you’ve ever looked into delivery pet food options, then you’ve likely heard of Ollie and Farmer’s Dog.
They’re both premium dog food delivery services that ship you fresh food on a weekly basis, right to your door, to provide your beloved canine companions with the high-value nutrients they need to sustain themselves, survive, and thrive with a healthy diet.
We all know that fresh food is so much better than cheap, dry, store-bought kibble.
But… is it really worth it to pay extra for high-quality dog food, especially when you could make homemade food yourself and know for sure what it’s made from?
In short, the answer is a definite ‘yes.’
Dog food has come a long way in recent years. Not only has there been a surge in pet food companies creating healthier options for all different dog breeds, but we’ve also seen a growing number of dog food delivery services popping up in recent years.
These services actually save a lot of time and don’t cost that much more than preparing the food yourself.
And Farmer’s Dog and Ollie are two such services. Both of these companies have a few things in common. But they also present their own fair share of differences.
Which one is better?
Which one will nourish your dog more, while also costing you less and providing the best dog food delivery service possible?
In this post, we’re going to dig deep and uncover the truth for all pet parents.
Farmer’s Dog vs Ollie: Features Comparison
At first glance, both of these dog food brands look similar.
Farmers Dog is labeled as “Smarter, Healthier Pet Food – real food, made fresh, delivered.”
While Ollie is labeled as “Healthy dog food for the long run – fresh, human-grade food made from real ingredients for a healthier pup today and tomorrow.”
So, let’s break both of these brands down, and compare them feature-by-feature.
How The Subscription Works: Ollie vs The Farmer’s Dog
Both Farmer’s Dog and Ollie feature subscription services that provide fresh dog food delivery directly to your doorstep.
Pet owners who use these services love them for not only their quality food offerings but also for the fact that you can get food delivered that’ll actually contribute to your dog’s health.
Let’s talk about how these subscription boxes work, first of all.
Farmer’s Dog Subscription Features
To learn what food and price options are available from Farmer’s Dog, you’ll need to fill out a bit of information to get started.
- How many dogs you have?
- Your zip code
- Your first name
- Your email address
- Your dog’s gender, age, weight, and breed
- Whether your dog is fixed or not
- Your dog’s body style
- The dog’s activity level
- How picky they are when eating
- Any health issues he/she has
- And other various things
This process is fast and easy for pet parents.
And right away, you’ll see the different plans that are well-suited to your dog.
You’ll also see that they don’t really offer a money-back guarantee, though you can get a refund for food your dog doesn’t like if you agree to donate that particular food to a shelter.
Farmer’s Dog Delivery
Farmer’s Dog delivers food portions within days of being cooked and prepared. Meals are delivered in eco-friendly packaging and timed to ensure that you never run out.
Different Food Options From Farmer’s Dog
For my dog (a 30-pound German Shepard mix), I was shown four different options.
All of these were made from freshly cooked, freshly packaged ingredients that were said to contain human-grade meat, vegetables, natural amino acids, antioxidants, and phytonutrients. They were also mostly grain-free. And each one was pre-portioned specifically to suit my dog’s age, weight, breed, etc.
Ollie Subscription Features
You’ll need to fill out some information to get started with Ollie. This is easy to do, and only takes a couple of minutes.
Here’s a list of some of what you can expect to provide:
- Your name
- Your email
- Your pet’s gender, name, breed, and date of birth
- Your dog’s current weight and ideal weight
- Whether or not your dog is fixed/neutered
- Your dog’s activity level
- What kind of food your dog eats now
After you fill in this information, Ollie crunches the numbers and creates some customized meal plan options. You get to customize your plan to a point, but for the most part, you’ll just choose between the different options available to decide which meals they’ll send you in your first box order.
You’ll also see that they also offer a money-back guarantee.
Ollie uses special modified atmospheric packaging to seal their fresh dog food trays. This means that you can count on them for fresh dog food delivery that’s airtight, without the use of dangerous preservatives or chemicals.
If you end up with too much food, you can also freeze it and move it to the refrigerator 24 hours before feeding.
They truly offer fresh food crafted with human-grade ingredients, shipped directly to your door.
Different Food Options From Ollie
Right away, I was shown 4 different fresh food meal options for my pet:
These were said to contain only human-grade ingredients, never any fillers or byproducts; so they’re mostly grain-free. Ollie also did a pretty good job of breaking down the specific ingredients and talking about their nutritional benefits, which was awesome.
I was pleased with how both companies broke down the ingredients in their foods. Knowing what you’re feeding your dog is crucial, and both companies did a great job of showing me exactly what could be found within their meals.
Food Head-to-Head | Ollie vs The Farmer’s Dog
To make sure that your dog is getting quality food and not just a bunch of cheap, thinly-sourced dry food or dry kibble, it’s important to take an honest, educated look at the food from a nutrition perspective.
Both of these services offer meat options like beef, turkey, and chicken. Plus, for my dog, Ollie offered a lamb option, while Farmer’s Dog offers a pork option.
I was also very pleased to see that both services meet AAFCO standards for dog food nutrient profiles for all life stages. These standards are set by Veterinary Nutritionists and are important for pet parents who want to make sure to feed only high-quality food.
But let’s dive in and get a more up-close look at the kind of nutrition the individual meals offer, to help you better gauge the impact that each meal may have on your dog’s health.
For reference, we’re going to break down one type of meal that both services offer… the turkey.
Farmer’s Dog Food Nutritional Breakdown
Here’s a look at the fresh dog food turkey meal Farmer’s Dog formulated for my dog.
- USDA Turkey
- Fish oil
It also contained a TFD Nutrient Blend that included the following: folic acid, vitamin D3, pyridoxine hydrochloride, tricalcium phosphate, sea salt, choline bitartrate, vitamin B12, taurine, zinc amino acid chelate, vitamin E, iron amino chelate, copper amino acid chelate, thiamine mononitrate, riboflavin, and potassium iodide.
Dry Matter Typical Analysis (compare to kibble)
- Protein – 38%
- Fat – 26%
- Fiber – 2%
As-Fed Guaranteed Analysis
- Crude Protein – 9% min.
- Crude Fat – 4.5% min.
- Crude Fiber – 1.5% max.
- Moisture – 76% max.
- 1170 kcal per kg / 530 kcal per lb
In other words, my 30 pound German Shepard mix with an active lifestyle, whose body style is ’round’ would be getting personalized portions of about 462 calories per day.
My Opinion On The Farmer’s Dog Food Nutritional Breakdown
Farmer’s Dog gives you all kinds of information to help you determine what ingredients their meals contain, the nutritional value of the meals, the calorie content, and more.
I give Farmer’s Dog high marks for providing so much information. I was also pleased with the food’s caloric content and found it to be quite appropriate to the normal amount I usually feed my pet.
I was also happy to see a wide range of different ingredients offered. For example, they offer chicken, turkey, beef, and pork meals. But in their pork meal plans, you get ingredients like green beans and sweet potato… while the chicken gives you brussels sprout, fish oil, bok choy, etc.
Ollie Dog Food Nutritional Breakdown
Here’s a look at the turkey dog food meal Ollie formulated for my pet.
- Turkey breast
- Turkey thigh
- Turkey liver, gizzard, and heart
- Chia seeds
- Coconut oil
- Dicalcium phosphate
- Calcium carbonate
- Cod liver oil
- Ferrous sulfate
- Vitamin E
- Manganese sulfate
- Potassium iodate
This is the guaranteed analysis provided by Ollie for their turkey meals:
- Protein – min 11%
- Fat – min 7%
- Fiber – max 2%
- Moisture – max 75%
- 1390 kcal per kg.
In other words, my 30 pound German Shepard mix with an active lifestyle, whose body style is ’round’ would be getting personalized portions of about 496 calories per day.
My Opinion On The Ollie Dog Food Nutritional Breakdown
I was happy with all of the information Ollie provided about their food. I was also happy to see them go so in-depth on the meat ingredients in their meals. For example, they didn’t just label the recipes ‘turkey, beef, etc.’ on the ingredient list.
They specifically tell you that you’re getting: beef heart, beef kidney, beef liver, etc. In their beef meals, you also get ingredients like peas, potato, and even sweet potatoes, chia seeds, and more.
Customer Feedback Comparison
For dog owners, researching customer feedback for these types of services is a smart way to make sure that your fresh dog food isn’t going to be a ‘big flop’ when you set it down in front of your pet.
Sure, statistics, formulations, and ingredient-lists look good on paper.
But how good is the customer service?
And perhaps most importantly; is your dog going to love the high-quality, human-grade ingredients just as much as they would enjoy homemade dog food?
To answer this question, we did a bunch of research online and scoured the internet for customer reports on both pet food brands (Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog).
Here’s what we found.
Farmer’s Dog Food Customer Feedback
For the most part, customers seem to love Farmer’s Dog Food. Customer service seems to be really good; dog owners seem to have mostly good things to say about Farmers Dog as a company, and their reputation seems to positive.
With that being said, we did spot a couple of complaints.
Some have said that they never received the food after ordering. This doesn’t seem to be a normal or regular occurrence. But apparently, it does happen from time to time.
There have also been a few reports of dogs losing interest in the food after a while.
This also doesn’t sound like a normal or frequent occurrence. But, it sounds like it has happened for at least a few of their customers.
Ollie Dog Food Customer Feedback
The vast majority of the reviews left online for Ollie’s fresh dog food are extremely positive. Dog owners seem to like the pet food, the customer service, and the meal ingredients.
With that being said, we did come across a couple of complaints.
Firstly, some people complained that packaging and shipping practices weren’t quite good enough. There have been complaints that there’s not enough dry ice included to keep the packages cold.
Secondly, there have been some complaints about customer service. Most people seem to love it. But some people have complained that Ollie customer service is, in general, hard to reach and get results with.
There have even been some rare reports of dogs getting sick on Ollie meals, and there have been a few rare reports that small bits of cooked bone were found in the food.
Ollie vs The Farmer’s Dog – Both Get Rave Customer Reviews
At the end of the day, we soured literally hundreds of customer reviews for these meals online. And we’re happy to report that both companies have a very, very high customer satisfaction rate.
It seems that problems with customer service are rare with both Ollie and The Farmer’s Dog. It also seems that problems with the pet food itself are also extremely rare. The vast majority of dog owners seem thrilled with the fresh dog food delivery meals from both companies.
Price Comparison: Ollie vs The Farmer’s Dog
Pricing is important.
You obviously want your dog to get the best, most balanced dog meal, created with the finest ingredients (chicken, turkey, beef, pork, etc.) and delivered in the correct portion sizes.
But you also need to be able to afford it.
Let’s take a look at the pricing information for both brands.
Both Ollie And The Farmer’s Dog Give You 50% Off Your First Order. One great feature of both brands (Farmer’s Dog, Ollie) is that you get 50 percent off your first box order. Both brands offer this, which means that you can try one or both at a discounted rate.
Farmer’s Dog gives you 50% off your first two weeks of meals. Ollie offers the exact same deal.
After the first two weeks, you’ll be bumped up to the full price.
Both Farmer’s Dog and Ollie offer free shipping, which is awesome.
Farmer’s Dog Food Pricing
According to the Farmer’s Dog website, plans start at $2 per day for the smallest dogs and then go up from there.
Farmer’s Dog priced my dog’s food (remember, he’s a 40-pound German Shepard) at $2.67 per day after applying the included first-order discount. You basically get 50% off the first two weeks of meals.
That comes out to $5.34 per day at full price.
In other words, ordering a two-week supply of meals from Farmer’s Dog for my pet would cost me $74.94 at full price.
Ollie Dog Food Pricing
According to the Ollie website, meal plans start at about $3 per day for the smallest dogs and then go up from there. Ollie priced a two-week meal plan for my dog at $2.66 per day after applying a first box 50% off coupon.
That comes out to $5.32 per day at full price.
In other words, ordering a two-week supply of meals for my pet from Ollie would cost me $74.42 at full price.
Ollie And The Farmer’s Dog – Who Gives You More Value For Your Money?
At the end of the day, both Ollie and the Farmer’s Dog are nearly identical in terms of pricing. You’ll pay only slightly more for Farmer’s Dog than you will for Ollie, but not really enough to notice a difference.
Why Use a Dog Food Delivery Service?
A lot of dog owners ask if using a fresh dog food delivery service is worth it. To this, the answer is generally a ‘yes,’ though it depends a bit on your specific situation.
Here’s the thing.
Dogs need at least one meal per day that gives them a balanced portion size. You don’t want grain and soy fillers. Rather, you want high quality foods (meats, sweet potato, carrots, beans, etc.).
You want food that would even make ‘Veterinary Nutritionists’ happy!
But, preparing those types of meals for dogs takes time. And honestly, it isn’t cheap. (You also don’t want to be one of those dog parents who puts cat food into the pet plate!)
Dog food delivery services take virtually all of the time-investment out of feeding your dogs healthy meals. It also helps you to save money, and is incredibly convenient.
You’re going to have to spend the money on your dog’s food somehow. You may as well get delicious, healthy pet food prepared and delivered right to your door, right?
Summary: Deciding if Farmer’s Dog or Ollie is Best for You
At the end of the day, making sure that your dog has the healthiest diet possible is the number-one goal. You also want it to be affordable, and you want to make sure that it’s also tasty and delicious.
Farmer’s Dog and Ollie each present a range of valuable upsides
They’re very similar in price, and they both offer high-grade ingredients, delivered freshly prepared and packaged right to your front door.
Personally, I liked the fact that you get 50% off on meals from both companies during the first two weeks, because this gives you an opportunity to try out both to see which one your dog likes more.
Honestly, these companies are so similar that it really all comes down to the taste, and what your dog does or doesn’t like for meals. Our expert opinion is to order both, see which meals your dog likes more, and then go with that option.
Your dog also may not like every meal from each service, so make sure to order all available meals… to figure out which options your pet is going to like more. Both are convenient, both seem to get high marks for customer service, and the quality of the food seems pretty equal between both companies.
So, consider trying them both out, and see which meal brand your pet enjoys more. That’s going to be the number-one biggest determining factor.
Try Farmer’s Dog Here:
Try Ollie Here: